OPEN A LITTLE BOX OF HAPP-PIE-NESS

Choose your flavors to fill your box.

Every mini pie is 3 inches. Six pies in each box.

For the Thanksgiving table

Mini Pie Packs — Thanksgiving Preorder

$20 per pack

Great for Friendsgiving. Choose your pack size, then choose each box of six. Every box can be a Variety Pack or six pies of one flavor.

Thanksgiving preorder · Order by November 20, 2026

Pickup + shipping

Pickup November 24–26 at Eastdale in Poughkeepsie.

Mini-only orders can ship ASAP or November 23. Orders with large pies or loaves ship together November 23.

Pickup times & order details

Pickup at 31 Eastdale Ave N, Poughkeepsie:

  • Tuesday, November 24: noon–7 pm
  • Wednesday, November 25: noon–7 pm
  • Thanksgiving Day, November 26: 10 am–2 pm

Shipping is available across the USA. Delivery takes 1–3 business days after shipment.

Ordering for today? Order Pickup/Delivery

This is our first Thanksgiving shipping pies and offering mini pie boxes. To keep up with the holiday rush, each box is one flavor or our Variety Pack. Custom flavor mixes within a box will be available after Thanksgiving.

Choose your flavors

$201 pack · 6 pies

Six pies per box. Each pack repeats your box selections.

Closed autumn mini pie box with the Just a Little Pie Shop logo

All boxed up.

Six mini pies in our autumn box.

Choose 6, 12, 18, or 24 of our 3-inch mini pies. Each box holds six pies: 6 pies is one box, 12 pies is two boxes, 18 pies is three boxes, and 24 pies is four boxes.

Choose each six-pie box independently: a Variety Pack with one each of Key Lime, Pumpkin, Pumpkin S’mores, Pecan, Apple Crumb, and Chocolate Cream, or six pies of one flavor. Combine different box choices in 12-, 18-, and 24-pie packs. Each quantity of 1 is one complete pack of the selected size.

Preorder by November 20, 2026. Pickup at Eastdale: November 24, 12–7 pm; November 25, 12–7 pm; or November 26, 10 am–2 pm.

Available for pickup or shipping within the United States. For mini-only orders, choose shipping as soon as possible or on Monday, November 23, 2026. Mini pies ordered with a large pie ship together on November 23. Delivery takes 1–3 business days after shipment.

Serving & storage

Follow the storage instructions for your pie below. Keep refrigerated pies covered at 40°F or below and cold until serving. Return these pies to the refrigerator within 2 hours, or 1 hour when the temperature is above 90°F. Remove boxes, wrapping and plastic lids before heating; use oven-safe bakeware.

Store
Refrigerate the complete pack.
Serve
Follow the instructions for each flavor. Remove individual apple pies if you would like to warm them; keep cream and custard pies chilled. Do not heat the gift box or plastic lids.