Key Lime Pie — Thanksgiving Preorder
Key Lime Pie — Thanksgiving Preorder
Thanksgiving preorder · Order by November 20, 2026
Pickup + shippingPickup November 24–26 at Eastdale in Poughkeepsie.
Shipping orders leave November 23. Mini pies ordered with large pies ship together.
Pickup times & order details
Pickup at 31 Eastdale Ave N, Poughkeepsie:
- Tuesday, November 24: noon–7 pm
- Wednesday, November 25: noon–7 pm
- Thanksgiving Day, November 26: 10 am–2 pm
Shipping is available across the USA. Delivery takes 1–3 business days after shipment.
Ordering for today? Order Pickup/Delivery
Couldn't load pickup availability
9-inch. Key lime pie.
Preorder by November 20, 2026. Pickup at Eastdale: November 24, 12–7 pm; November 25, 12–7 pm; or November 26, 10 am–2 pm.
Available for pickup or shipping within the United States. Large pies ship only on Monday, November 23, 2026. Any mini pies in the same order ship with them. Delivery takes 1–3 business days after shipment.
Serving & storage
Follow the storage instructions for your pie below. Keep refrigerated pies covered at 40°F or below and cold until serving. Return these pies to the refrigerator within 2 hours, or 1 hour when the temperature is above 90°F. Remove boxes, wrapping and plastic lids before heating; use oven-safe bakeware.
- Store
- Keep refrigerated.
- Serve
- Serve chilled. Keep these pies out of the oven so their fillings and toppings stay intact.